[Skip to Content]
Menu
  • Overview
  • Program
  • Register
  • My Account
Menu
  • Home
  • SETAC North America 47th Annual Meeting Session/Event Gallery
  • Can I Trust Your Data? Data Quality Issues in Modern Ecotoxicology
  • Data Quality Issues in Deriving Environmental Quality Standards Under the European Water Framework Directive: A Growing Culture of Misuse and Mistrust?

7.03.T-02 - Data Quality Issues in Deriving Environmental Quality Standards Under the European Water Framework Directive: A Growing Culture of Misuse and Mistrust?

Abstract

The Water Framework Directive (WFD) is a unifying piece of legislation that brings together existing national and European commitments on water resources and water quality. One of the tools to be used to meet these legal commitments are Environmental Quality Standards (EQS) derived for chemicals that are deemed to present a European-wide risk to surface waters. These EQS are ‘limits’ above which a chemical is considered to present potential aquatic risk. In Europe the derivation of these quality standards, which are legally binding, regulatory ‘bright-lines’, enshrined in national legislation, is performed by the European Commission’s technical contractors, and by individual member state (country) regulators, with very limited stakeholder influence or input.
Protocols have been published detailing the scientific derivation process to be followed, and schemes to evaluate the reliability and relevance of effects and exposure data are readily available (e.g. CRED (Criteria for Reporting and Evaluating ecotoxicity Data) and CREED (Criteria for Reporting and Evaluating Exposure Datasets)). European-wide EQS are derived by considering both effects (ecotoxicity) and exposure (measured chemical concentrations in the environment) data. However, in the most recent round of EQS derivations and substance prioritisations performed clear challenges in regulatory trust have emerged, including:
• The dismissing of reliable and relevant effects and exposure data, especially those provided by stakeholders (data from studies funded by industry are considered “biased”);
• Misuse (or non use) of data to reach a specific outcome (numerical value);
• The lack of provision of all data used in the derivations, meaning it is not possible to review or repeat assessments or verify findings.
A scientific process that is not transparent or consistent engenders mistrust and scepticism and is unlikely to lead to robust or relevant environmental outcomes. In this presentation we will attempt to identify the triggers for this recent culture shift, and flag what we believe to be the ongoing contributory factors perpetuating this misuse and mistrust and ultimately the resulting suboptimal environmental outcomes. We will also recommend steps to be taken to increase trust in scientific data generation in regulatory processes, and how we can ensure its effective and transparent use to inform regulatory and governmental decisionmakers.

Author(s)

Presenter: Iain Wilson, wca environment Ltd.,
Authors:
Iain Wilson wca environment Ltd. United Kingdom
Graham Merrington wca environment Ltd. United Kingdom
Dean Leverett wca environment Ltd. United Kingdom



 
















7.03.T-02 - Data Quality Issues in Deriving Environmental Quality Standards Under the European Water Framework Directive: A Growing Culture of Misuse and Mistrust?

Presentation Format

Platform presentation

  • Society of Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry
    setac.org

Cookies are small text files that are used to store small pieces of information. The cookies are stored on your device when the website is loaded on your browser. These cookies help us make the website function properly, make the website more secure, provide better user experience, and understand how the website performs and to analyze what works and where it needs improvement.